hunting-hadamards
census · order 49

vxvware-kkss-n49

reproduced
Challenge resultNot yet published

[11] report a complete classification of cyclic families with symmetric or skew blocks for odd v < 50 and find none of type (kkss) at v=49, where the only parameter set of that type is (49; 24,24,22,18; 39). The vxvware census finds eight quadruples with exactly that parameter set, one equiv-v1 class, and the rows verify exactly on this board. The same program reproduces the published counts at v=33, 37, 41, 43, and 45.

Original source attribution: vxvware
Submitted / imported by: vxvware · 2026-10-15
Board cell: G-matrices (kkss)
Entry file: census/vxvware-kkss-n49.json · raw JSON

Notes

The source reports a full census with 1 class under its own equivalence convention and stores 8 quadruples. This board verifies the 1 equiv-v1 representative and records a lower bound; the search has not been replayed here. Contradicts arXiv:1802.00556, whose exhaustive search reports no G-matrices at v=49 for the parameter set (49; 24,24,22,18; 39). The rows here have exactly that parameter set and verify exactly on this board.

Checks and result

{
  "id": "vxvware-kkss-n49",
  "type": "census",
  "n": 49,
  "stratum": "kkss",
  "equivalence": "equiv-v1",
  "count": 1,
  "bound": "exact",
  "tier": "reproduced",
  "claimed_count": 1,
  "claim_kind": "lower-bound",
  "checks": [
    "pairwise-inequivalence",
    "registered-full-census-replay",
    "representative-existence"
  ],
  "replay": {
    "engine_id": "kkss-census-c-v1",
    "host": "bos-game",
    "threads": 4,
    "date": "2026-11-13",
    "wall_seconds": 520.0,
    "raw_rows": 8
  },
  "limitations": [
    "Full offline replay of a pinned engine, re-derived from its raw rows here; the same engine can reproduce its own systematic bugs."
  ],
  "contributions": [
    {
      "id": "kkss-49-correction",
      "title": "G-matrices at n=49, contradicting a published nonexistence statement",
      "relation": "participant-result",
      "publication_status": "unpublished",
      "contributors": [
        {
          "name": "vxvware",
          "github": "vxvware"
        }
      ],
      "summary": "[@djokovic2018goethals] report a complete classification of cyclic families with symmetric or skew blocks for odd v < 50 and find none of type (kkss) at v=49, where the only parameter set of that type is (49; 24,24,22,18; 39). The vxvware census finds eight quadruples with exactly that parameter set, one equiv-v1 class, and the rows verify exactly on this board. The same program reproduces the published counts at v=33, 37, 41, 43, and 45.",
      "entry_ids": [
        "n49-703082c3c1ffa487f376",
        "vxvware-kkss-n49"
      ],
      "featured": true,
      "stratum": "kkss",
      "label": "Challenge result",
      "position": 0,
      "recorded_at": "2026-10-15"
    }
  ]
}

Sources

Submission JSON
{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "n": 49,
  "group": {
    "kind": "cyclic",
    "invariant_factors": [
      49
    ]
  },
  "submitted_by": "vxvware",
  "submitted_at": "2026-10-15",
  "discovered_by": [
    "vxvware"
  ],
  "sources": [
    {
      "title": "vxvware/saw-best-matrix: G-matrices (kkss) at n=49 (archived in this repository)",
      "url": "https://github.com/vxvware/goethals-seidel-challenge/blob/f29ee8912110f79163da774997b21f9289d4027f/evidence/participants/saw-best-matrix/gmat/gmat-49.txt",
      "commit": "8aaf08f4352a0b0787e7ff6c670a9c326de2f23f",
      "source_path": "data/gmat/gmat-49.txt",
      "artifact": {
        "path": "evidence/participants/saw-best-matrix/gmat/gmat-49.txt",
        "sha256": "e96ad52183f15d10b21da0ffcd99b5aa72456ddaed5eda7fa6eadeac9699570f"
      }
    }
  ],
  "equivalence": "equiv-v1",
  "id": "vxvware-kkss-n49",
  "type": "census",
  "stratum": "kkss",
  "representatives": [
    "n49-703082c3c1ffa487f376"
  ],
  "claimed_count": 1,
  "claim_kind": "lower-bound",
  "secondary": {
    "stored_rows": 8
  },
  "notes": "The source reports a full census with 1 class under its own equivalence convention and stores 8 quadruples. This board verifies the 1 equiv-v1 representative and records a lower bound; the search has not been replayed here. Contradicts arXiv:1802.00556, whose exhaustive search reports no G-matrices at v=49 for the parameter set (49; 24,24,22,18; 39). The rows here have exactly that parameter set and verify exactly on this board."
}